Is A Mormon A Christian? Who Should Answer That Question?
I was active in speech and debate at Excelsior High School in Norwalk, California. It was good for me to be part of a group where I fit in and felt comfortable. My debate partner for several years, Lynn, was a Mormon. She was a good friend and asked if I wanted to attend a class on Saturday to learn more about the Mormon faith. I agreed and attended. Following the class my parents gently, but clearly informed me that Mormons could be a cult and I needed to be careful about getting too close. It was the only time I recall them warning me about a girlfriend or a religion.
For the last three decades I have been actively seeking better information about other religions and spiritualities. I have been blessed with many friends who have shared their faith journey with me and have been gracious in listening as I have shared mine with them. My work with The Greater Kansas City Interfaith Council has been a significant arena for my passion for celebrating the gifts of religious pluralism.
In recent years the presence of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Days Saints (commonly called Mormon) has been more and more in the limelight. It appears likely that the Republican Party will nominate a Mormon to be their candidate for president and this has resurfaced the questions that my parents raised decades ago. The soon to be dedicated Temple not far from my home has added further pressure for me to respond to the questions about Mormons and Christians.
In the early days of the Jesus movement when Christianity was morphing from a cult within Judaism into a major religion it was important to define who was in and who was out. Creeds were developed to clearly establish what it meant to be “Christian” in a world of tremendous diversity. For centuries the Christian establishment controlled who could be identified as part of this major world religion. Times have changed. Christianity, like many other world religions, has evolved and divided into numerous branches and not so unlike the early church, one can find rich diverse theologies, practices, rituals, and beliefs all identifying themselves as part of the Christian family. I find this rich diversity a gift and have discovered deep meaning in the various branches I have experienced.
I would not imagine asking another Lutheran, or Roman Catholic, or Baptist, or Quaker, or Assembly of God, etc. “Are you Christian?” Although we differ on many things, we respect each other enough to allow self-definitions to suffice. Therefore, I would offer the following easy solution. If you want to know about another faith group, get to know someone who is part of that group and interview them. Ask respectful questions about their personal experience with the faith and why it is meaningful for them. Ask the questions and really listen to their responses. Listen for understanding, not to correct them or challenge them. If a Mormon answers, “I am a Christian” I totally accept that and seek to learn more about their faith life. Let’s quite talking about others so much and start listening to and talking to each other.
Would Mitt Romney be a good president of the United States? I don’t know. I know I won’t be voting for him, but that is not because he is Mormon. Do Mormons have some teaching and practices we can learn from? Their commitment to family is impressive. Their insistence about preparedness for the future seems like an excellent idea. Their commitment to stewardship impresses me. I have been told that before the first shovel went into the ground for their new Temple, the entire project had been paid for. Does the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints have doctrines I do not understand? Yes, and I hope to learn more about them in the coming months. Do Mormons make good debate partners? I knew one that sure was good and she was a joy to know. We were good together. In the coming weeks take some time, if you are interested, to learn about some of your neighbors. February 8th at 1 p.m. we will learn more about the new Temple in the Kansas City Northland. For several weeks The Greater Kansas City Interfaith Book Club is studying The Book of Mormon. There will be continued reflections in the media throughout this presidential election season. I encourage all of us to keep talking with each other and far less talk about each other.
